Make-up Gifts for Expert Eyes

  • They say good things come in threes, but we're overachievers! We just had to give you a whole list, so check out all these ideas for gift inspiration. Our Gift Gurus are constantly scouting out products, and there's nothing they like more than sharing their new finds with you. Enjoy the show and share your favorites on Pinterest or Facebook! --
    Next:
  • Kat Von D Tattoo Liner Trooper 0.02 oz
    MY GIFT LISTS
    Achieve dramatic eyes and create temporary tattoos with this water-resistant must-have that brings out the artist in you. The innovative brush tip makes it easy to make your personal vision a reality.
    Next:
  • Urban Decay Naked Palette
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A universally flattering palette that features 12 eye shadows with a distinctly Urban look. This long, lean, and seductive case comes packed with 12 gorgeous neutrals that work for absolutely everyone. Shades range from delicate champagne to gritty gunmetal, and feature five stunning new shades. A variety of textures, including glitter, shimmer, and matte, ensure that you'll never get bored....
    Next:
  • MAKE UP FOR EVER Glitters in Sand
    MY GIFT LISTS
    All that glitters! These lightweight, fine particles of bright light add glamour to any type of makeup—on the face or body. A little bit goes a long way. Just pat on the skin with a wet brush for a long-lasting effect.
    Next:
  • Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Crayon in Jazz (Berry)
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A gel crayon eyeliner with a waterproof, long-wearing, color-intense payoff.
    Next:
  • Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Crayon in Th (Ink)
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A gel crayon eyeliner with a waterproof, long-wearing, color-intense payoff.
    Next:
  • Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Crayon in N (Ice)
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A gel crayon eyeliner with a waterproof, long-wearing, color-intense payoff.
    Next:
  • Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Crayon in Intro (Vert)
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A gel crayon eyeliner with a waterproof, long-wearing, color-intense payoff.
    Next:
  • Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Crayon in Blacquer
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A gel crayon eyeliner with a waterproof, long-wearing, color-intense payoff.
    Next:
  • MY GIFT LISTS
    This must-have follow-up to the bestselling Jemma Kidd Make-up Masterclass will show you how to create the perfect look.
    Next:
  • Marc Jacobs Beauty Style Eye-Con No.3 - Plush Shadow The Punk 104
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A petite set of three plush eyeshadows that harmoniously marry with a creamy, sumptuous finish. Each mini palette of shimmery metallics, buttery mattes, and lustrous sheens are made with advanced pigments that allow true, instant color payoff and long-lasting, plush performance. Shades are cleverly sized to suit your eyeshadow needs.
    Next:
  • Make Up For Ever Pure Pigments No. 14 0.12 oz
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A highly pigmented loose powder. Make Up For Ever Pure Pigments contains a high color concentration that can be used on the eyes or lips. You can mix it in with your clear gloss to create your own personalized color, apply it on the lid for a swash of color, or create a liner by applying with a wet brush. Play with the color to create a rich pigment that pops.
    Next:
  • Too Faced The Chocolate Bar Eye Palette
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A sweetly tempting array of 16 matte and shimmer shadows scented with real chocolate. This beautiful assortment of chocolate-inspired shades were formulated using real cocoa powder. Encased in a playful chocolate bar tin, the rich selection of the perfect browns, neutrals, and little pops of color appeal to every candy lover.
    Next:
  • Anastasia Beverly Hills
    MY GIFT LISTS
    Sculpt and define your brows with Dipbrow Pomade waterproof brow color by Anastasia Beverly Hills. The smudge-free, creamy formula glides smoothly onto your skin, adhering to hair for the perfect precise brow.
    Next:
  • Lit Cosmetics Holographic Glitter Kit in Silver
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A three-piece kit for designing a holographic glitter look for the eyes. Add holographic sheen to any look with this kit created for clean and controlled glitter application.
    Next:
  • Lit Cosmetics Holographic Glitter Kit in Gold
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A three-piece kit for designing a holographic glitter look for the eyes. Add holographic sheen to any look with this kit created for clean and controlled glitter application. "Clearly Liquid" glitter base keeps all loose product adhered to eyelids and lashes including all other skin surfaces. This formula also provides a comfortable protective layer over your base makeup, keeping...
    Next:
  • Lit Cosmetics Holographic Glitter Kit in Purple
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A three-piece kit for designing a holographic glitter look for the eyes. Add holographic sheen to any look with this kit created for clean and controlled glitter application. "Clearly Liquid" glitter base keeps all loose product adhered to eyelids and lashes including all other skin surfaces. This formula also provides a comfortable protective layer over your base makeup, keeping colors...
    Next:
  • Buxom Red Hot Set
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A four-piece Buxom color collection for sexy cat eyes & scarlet lips. This four-piece collection is your key to creating your signature cat eye and hot, red lip. With sleek, sexy winged eyeliner, larger-than-life lashes, and shiny scarlet lips you’ve got everything you need to be red hot.
    Next:
  • Too Faced Cause A Scandal
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A four-piece collection with everything you need to create scandal-worthy eyes. Cause A Scandal with Too Faced's eye favorites, including all the essentials to create endless eye looks for the bedroom and beyond. Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Primer is a skin-soothing formula to even out skintone and smooth the look of fine lines to create the perfect canvas for shadows. Color is intensified...
    Next:
  • Lit Cosmetics No Glitter No Glory Kit inTinsel Town
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A loose color glitter and a clear liquid glitter base that keeps glitter eye makeup firmly in place. Achieve clean and controlled glitter application with this product that contains all natural ingredients. It also provides a comfortable protective layer over your base makeup keeping colors bright and crease free without cracking or fading.
    Next:
  • Bobbi Brown & L'Wren Scott
    MY GIFT LISTS
    The Amnesia Rose palette features a range of sophisticated, luxurious, wearable shades for your eyes, cheeks and lips. It’s a collaboration between Bobbi and her friend L’Wren Scott, inspired by the latter’s favorite flower. The hues come packaged in a notebook-style palette with hand-drawn fashion sketches on the cover.
    Next:
  • Too Faced Paparazzi Ready
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A five-piece collection of the perfect eyeliner, lash-defining mascara, nude lip gloss, Beauty Balm, and a chocolate scented matte bronzer. Ready for your closeup? This five-piece collection of camera-ready beauty powerhouses includes the best of eyes, face, and lips that Too Faced has to offer.
    Next:
  • Anastasia Beverly Hills Five Item Brow Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    What it does: Indispensable tools for brow shaping.Why it's great: All the basics in one place, available in five shades to accommodate any hair color at an amazing price.
    Next:
  • Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    Dreamy and creamy eye color from Pixi - in a set of 5 fave colors!
    Next:
  • Lancome
    MY GIFT LISTS
    For lavishly long, perfectly defined lashes, this iconic award-winning mascara provides the ultimate in separation. Carefully selected polymers coat each lash from root to tip to help lengthen and outline each lash for unmatched definition. This best-selling mascara's unique brush applicator has specially grooved bristles that hold the perfect amount...
    Next:
  • Smashbox Santigolden Age Eye Shadow Collage in Earth As We Know It
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A one-of-a-kind collaged and mirrored palette with five dramatic wet-to-dry eyeshadows. This limited-edition luxe, collectible palette contains five vivid, shimmery shades with seriously serpentine details, from the snake-shaped interior down to the texture, which mimics a snake’s scales. The exterior of the mirrored compact features a unique collage created by Santigold with the artist...
    Next:
  • Smashbox Santigolden Age Eye Shadow Collage in Apocalypse Now
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A one-of-a-kind collaged and mirrored palette with five dramatic wet-to-dry eyeshadows. This limited-edition luxe, collectible palette contains five vivid, shimmery shades with seriously serpentine details, from the snake-shaped interior down to the texture, which mimics a snake’s scales. The exterior of the mirrored compact features a unique collage created by Santigold with the artist...
    Next:
  • Urban Decay Electric Pressed Pigment Palette
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A bright collection of 10 velvety, pressed-pigment shadows that deliver an insane color payout. The ultimate fix for color addicts, this palette features smooth mattes and highly-dimensional shimmery shades. Each soft, creamy, long-wearing powder is electrically colorful, and carefully crafted with a smooth formula that applies vibrantly. Pressed pigments create heavily saturated bright...
    Next:
  • Too Faced Pardon My French Set
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A limited-edition set ideal for creating a classic summer eye. Available only for a limited time, this exclusive set inspired by the French Riviera contains all the eye products you need for a fresh summer look. Great for travel, it all zips into a striped St. Tropez-ready makeup bag.
    Next:
  • Too Faced Brow Envy Brow Shaping & Defining Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    This foolproof palette contains everything a glamour girl needs to shape, define, fill, and set brows. It features customizable color for brunettes and blondes: simply use the stencils and mix the two shades for your ideal brow shape and color.
    Next:
  • Make Up Forever Extravagant Lashes Set
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A daring duo to create extravagant lashes and easily remove it. Enhance lashes with volume, length, curl, and precision using Smoky Extravagant’s Procision 4D Technology. Its two-in-one, cone-shape brush has a precision tip that separates lashes as the rounded base creates extravagant volume from any distance. Quickly and easily remove it with Sens’Eyes. Ideal for sensitive eyes, this ultragent...
    Next:
  • Sephora Collection Color My Life Eye & Lip Makeup Tablet
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A tablet palette featuring 36 eye shadows and six lip glosses, organized into looks for any occasion. Be ready for any adventure with this adorable pink palette packed with 36 flattering eye shadow shades for complete eye makeup. With matte, shimmery, and glitter effects, from light to bright and dark shades, there’s sure to be something to suit every mood.
    Next:
  • theBalm
    MY GIFT LISTS
    Hit it out of the park with Schwing, a rich, long-lasting liquid eyeliner that lines and defines with a marvelously matte-black finish. Create winning looks with the smudge-proof, easy-to-use formula that doesn't flake or take forever to dry. Perfect for girls on the go.Lining and defining eyes has never been easier.
    Next:
  • ARDENCY INN PUNKER Smoky Eye Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A limited-edition kit designed to create a rock star smoky eye look in an instant. Consider this your trio of rock star makeup essentials. Punker Original Smoky Shadow is a waterproof, matte charcoal eye shadow that blends easily into a diffused smoke effect. The World's Baddest Eyeliner comes in a short and thick pen with an oversized felt tip applicator that makes it easy to precisely...
    Next:
  • Dior Diorshow Catwalk Eye Makeup Set
    MY GIFT LISTS
    An award-wining, catwalk-classic mascara and eye makeup remover duo. The mascara delivers plush, glam lashes with an innovative XXL brush for show-stopping volume. Its creamy, buildable, customizable formula allows you to achieve the same dramatic lash volume that can be seen on the Dior runway for a glamorous, false-lash effect.
    Next:
  • Tweezerman Mini Brow Rescue Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A travel-size quartet with all you need for a brow quick-fix, right at your fingertips. This four-piece set helps create perfectly defined, head-turning brows in no time. The hot pink, award-winning mini slant tweezer features stellar quality and expert precision, allowing you to grab every hair. Browmousse coaxes brows to stay in place all day long with a superior clear-gel formula that...
    Next:
  • Too Faced Better Than Sex Amazing Eyes Set
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A dramatic duo for smudge-proof eyes and pumped up lashes. Consider this your perfectly portable power couple. Better Than Sex Mascara gives lashes voluptuous drama, and Perfect Eyes Eyeliner locks down for more than eight hours of smudge-proof wear.
    Next:
  • Sephora Favorites Summerstash
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A multibranded collection of nine sample size, warm-weather must-haves. Get set on summer: from sun-kissed skin to popsicle-stained lips, this collection packs all your warm-weather must-haves in one place. This set inspired by summer getaways includes all the essentials for your sunny days: from makeup setting spray to bronzer to a coconut-cheek blush to longwear lacquered mascara, this...
    Next:
  • Givenchy The Art of Mascara Set
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A luxurious set that includes a revolutionary lash formula and lip color. Phenomen’Eyes is designed to grip lashes at the roots to curl and separate. It has a high-tech, patented round sphere at the tip of the precision wand that reaches every lash and adapts to all eye shapes. For perfectly defined lips that last, this lipstick-as-accessory delivers intense colors and a semimatte finish...
    Next:
  • Make Up Forever Birthday Beautiful Set
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A limited-edition set with four universal formulas to complement and enhance a special look. This makeup bag is filled with products for an elegant birthday fête. Talc-free HD Pressed Powder softens the appearance of fine lines and pores. Universally flattering Lip Line Perfector works with any lip color to prevent feathering as it fills in fine lines. Aqua Eyes waterproof eyeliner in metallic...
    Next:
  • Lit Cosmetics Summer Sparkle Lit Kit in Hello Sunshine
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A high-performance, high-sparkle kit with loose glitter, clear liquid glitter base, and a brush for the ultimate glitz. This set is designed to give a clean, controlled loose glitter application. The Clearly Liquid Base adheres glitter to skin and nail surfaces, adding all-day shine that stays where you want it.
    Next:
  • Lit Cosmetics Summer Sparkle Lit Kit in Afternoon Delight
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A high-performance, high-sparkle kit with loose glitter, clear liquid glitter base, and a brush for the ultimate glitz. This set is designed to give a clean, controlled loose glitter application. The Clearly Liquid Base™ adheres glitter to skin and nail surfaces, adding all-day shine that stays where you want it.
    Next:
  • Stila Most Wanted Vol. II Eye Liner Duo
    MY GIFT LISTS
    Two of Stila’s bestselling eyeliners in one exclusive set. Draw the perfect line every time with Stila's bestselling Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner in Intense Black and Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner in Violet, a vibrant matte purple. These beloved cult classics deliver deeply pigmented color in waterproof formulas that stay in place until you say when.
    Next:
  • Kelly Osbourne for MAC
    MY GIFT LISTS
    Kelly Osbourne joins forces with MAC for a limited-edition collection of showstopping products for your face, lips and eyes all wrapped up in light violet packaging. Penultimate Jumbo Eyeliner gives you fastidiously smooth, precisely deep lines in jet-fast speed. The versatile product is designed to go on thick but is able to create a superfine line, too.
    Next:
  • Sephora Collection Dramatic Performance Longwear Lash Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A professionally inspired lash kit designed for long-wear use. Create long-lasting lash extensions without the trip to the salon. This set is customizable for any occasion, thanks to the specially designed inner and outer lashes that create a conservative or glam lash look. The Bulls Eye applicator and uniquely formulated lash adhesive allow for expert application and ensure long-wear...
    Next:
  • Too Faced 5 Star Favorites
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A bestselling trio featuring a deluxe eye shadow primer, black eyeliner, and mascara for dramatic eye looks. Get sexy eyes with these Too Faced essentials. This deluxe eye set includes Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow Primer for crease-proof, fade-proof, 24-hour shadow wear, Perfect Eyes Eye Liner in Black for added definition, and Better Than Sex Mascara for extreme volume and...
    Next:
  • Benefit Cosmetics Instant Glamification
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A trio of waterproof eyeliners that glide on effortlessly for glamorous or smoky eye looks. These three mini BADgal waterproof liners deliver even lines for luxe looks, and they can be smudged out for an intense smoky eye. In three budge-proof shades to choose from, these liners feature a hue for every way that you want to wear eyeliner.
    Next:
  • Tarte Be Charmed Limited Edition Picture Perfect Eyelash Curler
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A limited-edition picture perfect™ eyelash curler with an included charm and a deluxe sample of Lights, Camera, Flashes™ Statement Mascara. A “charming” addition to any eyelash wardrobe, this dark bamboo-inspired Picture Perfect eyelash curler delivers an instant and dramatic curl that’s sure to take lashes above and beyond. The ergonomic design and easy grip handle deliver a painless,...
    Next:
  • 3 Pack Hourglass 1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner Obsidian
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A thin and soft, waterproof gel eyeliner encapsulated in a 1.5MM mechanical pencil. Bring dramatic definition and the staying power of a traditional gel eyeliner without the gel pot with this precision tip, waterproof eyeliner. This eyeliner provides precision accuracy and ease of application in just two clicks and one stroke allowing you to create a variety of eye looks that are transfer-free...
    Next:
  • Sephora Favorites Draw The Line
    MY GIFT LISTS
    An eyeliner sampler set including one full size product for creating multiple eye looks. This set features liquid, gel, and pencil liners that let you flick, drag, sweep, or smudge on liner. Create countless looks with multiple formulas for precise pigmented application, inner rim lining, long-wear, contouring, and subtle to smoky looks.
    Next:
  • Givenchy Les Mini Prismes
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A mini compact box that includes Givenchy makeup must-haves for eyes, face, and cheeks, plus two applicators in universally flattering shades. This sophisticated, compact box holds all you need for the ultimate Givenchy style. The Le Prisme Yeux Quator in Purple Show 71 eye shadow quad features extremely soft powders in elegant complementary colors and long-lasting formulas. Le Prisme...
    Next:
  • MAKE UP FOR EVER Artist Palette
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A limited-edition eye shadow palette featuring the season's must-have shades to perfectly complement your favorite eye looks.
    Next:
  • MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Brow Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A three-piece brow kit that gives you a natural-looking set of eyebrows while filling, lengthening, and defining them. Getting well-groomed arches just got easier. This kit includes a highly pigmented, fade-free, and waterproof formula gel to enhance and reshape natural brows for a strong hold, and it comes with must-have angled and spiral brushes to groom and soften for flawless eyebrows...
    Next:
  • Stila Eyes Are the Window Shadow Palettes in Body
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A luxurious palette with 12 eye shadows, curated to illuminate the wearer’s inner beauty. Inspired by the spiritual notion that true beauty is revealed from within, Stila created endless looks with this Eyes Are The Window™ Shadow Palette. These carefully curated palettes mirror an aspect of inner beauty: Mind, Body, Spirit, Soul. Each palette inculdes 12 luxe eye shadows that range from...
    Next:
  • Stila Eyes Are the Window Shadow Palettes in Soul
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A luxurious palette with 12 eye shadows, curated to illuminate the wearer’s inner beauty. Inspired by the spiritual notion that true beauty is revealed from within, Stila created endless looks with this Eyes Are The Window™ Shadow Palette. These carefully curated palettes mirror an aspect of inner beauty: Mind, Body, Spirit, Soul. Each palette inculdes 12 luxe eye shadows that range from...
    Next:
  • Marc Jacobs Beauty Style Eye-Con No.7 Plush Shadow in The Dreamer
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A super skinny, sleek palette of seven eye shadows that harmoniously marry with a creamy, sumptuous finish. A super skinny and sleek design will instantly make these seven harmonized shadows become your eye essentials. Each palette of shimmery metallics, buttery mattes, and lustrous sheens are made with advanced pigments that allow true, instant color payoff, and long-lasting plush performanc...
    Next:
  • SEPHORA COLLECTION Chroma Color Eye Palette
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A luxe makeup palette that is all about eyes. With 54 eye shadows, 12 eye pencils, and a double-ended eye shadow brush, this astounding palette allows you to create an endless number of eye looks. Experiment and play with a wide variety of colors, from must-have nudes to intense smoky shades and more vibrant tones in a variety of finishes. Let your imagination be your guide. The sky's the limit!
    Next:
  • Benefit Cosmetics The Real Steal
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A limited-edition, eye makeup set featuring a full size They’re Real! Mascara, a mini They’re Real! Push-Up Liner, and a They’re Real! Remover sample. What it does: This bonus eye set from Benefit lets you create bigger, sexier eyes and long lashes with Benefit’s bestselling mascara and lash-hugging, gel push-up liner pen. Then take it all off with the waterproof, They’re Real! eye...
    Next:
  • Kat Von D Immortal Lash & Line Kit
    MY GIFT LISTS
    A set of essentials for round-the-clock, striking eyes featuring a full-size Immortal Lash 24HR Mascara and deluxe-size Tattoo Liner.
    Next:
  • Kat Von D Tattoo Liner Trooper 0.02 oz
    THEY ALSO
    MIGHT LIKE...

LET US HELP YOU FIND THE PERFECT GIFT

Find a
gift for a
that’s